Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Rationed healthcare

This is a gem I waited to post. From our friend Dick and Dick believes rationing healthcare not an answer. Alas Dick, we are rationed already; from the insurance companies and HMOs.:

This is copyrighted and I shall withdraw if objections made:

May 14, 2009
Only Way to Reduce Costs is to Ration HealthcareBy Dick Morris

When all of America's top health insurers and providers met at the White House this week and pledged to save $2 trillion over the next decade in health costs, they were pledging to sabotage our medical care. The blunt truth, which everybody agreed to keep quiet, is that the only way to reduce these costs is to ration healthcare, thereby destroying our system.

Here's why:

• Essential to any cost reduction is a cut in doctors' fees. Congress is trying to cut Medicare fees by 21 percent. But cuts in fees and doctors' incomes will just discourage people from entering the profession and those already in it from practicing. The limited number of doctors and nurses in the United States is the key constraint on the availability of healthcare. Our national inventory of 800,000 doctors is growing at only about 1 percent a year (18,000 med school graduates annually minus retirements), while the nurse population is stagnant at 1.4 million. To stretch these limited resources so that they can treat 50 million more people is possible only through the most severe kind of rationing.

• As in Canada, the best way to cut medical costs is to refrain from using the best drugs to treat cancer and other illnesses, thereby economizing at the expense of patients' lives. Forty-four percent of the drugs approved by the Canadian health authorities for use in their country are not allowed by the healthcare system due to their high cost. As a result, death rates from cancer are 16 percent higher in Canada than in the United States. We will pay for the attempt to save $2 trillion with our lives. (And remember, one cannot opt out of the Canadian system and pay for the medications out of pocket.)

• The only real way to save money on the scale projected is to ration healthcare services. Optimists say that this can be achieved by increased use of preventive care. But the Canadian experience indicates that when government - or its satellite private insurance providers - ration healthcare, they cut preventive care first. In Canada, colonoscopies are so rationed that the colon cancer rate is 25 percent higher than in the U.S. (even though Canada has a much smaller proportion of poor people, whose frequently bad diets make them more prone to the disease).
Obama's pretension that nobody will find changes in his or her current health insurance plans except for a magical reduction in their cost by $2,500 a year is a fool's proposition. Private health insurers will be no more private than TARP-funded banks or government-subsidized car companies are in Obama's America. They will be controlled by government healthcare planners who will approve treatments, limit drug use, hold down medical incomes and bring their cost-cutting programs to bear. Inevitably, their ax will fall on the oldest and the sickest among us, those least "deserving" of our newly limited and, under Obama's program, diminishing healthcare resources.

The other radical changes Obama is bringing about in our nation can always be reversed. New taxes can be repealed or lowered. That which was nationalized can be privatized. Government which has grown can be cut. But once the healthcare system is extended to cover everyone, with no commensurate increase in the resources available, the change will be forever. The vicious cycle of cuts in medical resources and in the number of doctors and nurses will doom healthcare in this country. This wanton destruction will not be reversible by any bill or program. A crucial part of our quality of life - the best healthcare in the world - will be gone forever.

Politically, voters will feel the impact of these "reforms" very quickly. When they face rejection or limitation at the hands of the bureaucrats, they will quickly understand that their options have become limited. Just as in the 1990s, when HMOs first became universal, the patient outrage will create a political force all its own and those who foisted this brave new world on the American people will be in their crosshairs.

Morris, a former political adviser to Sen. Trent Lott (R-Miss.) and President Bill Clinton, is the author of "Outrage." To get all of Dick Morris’s and Eileen McGann’s columns for free by email, go to www.dickmorris.com.

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2009/05/14/death_of_us_healthcare__96474.html
at June 01, 2009

Friday, May 29, 2009

Baucus flees from single payer question

Last week, this vid was made and Max Baucus flees from single payer question.


GM? is the deal a raw one

This is another interesting article from the Wall Street Journal. It is a copyrighted article that brings up many interesting points. I shall withdraw if objections made:

MAY 29, 2009
Obama's GM Plan Looks Like a Raw Deal Congress, not a secret task force, should decide the company's fate
. Article more in Opinion »Email Printer By RALPH NADER and ROBERT WEISSMAN

What public purposes animate the government's planned rescue of General Motors Corp? David Gothard Millions of people in communities across the country depend on the government getting the GM rescue right. That's why it is startling -- and mistaken -- for the future of GM to rest with a small, largely unaccountable, ad hoc task force made up of a handful of Wall Street expats.

A congressional abdication of authority of historic proportions has left the executive branch with nearly complete discretion over how to handle GM and Chrysler's restructuring. President Barack Obama has further delegated authority, giving effective control to this task force, which operates under the titular authority of a top-level interagency group headed by National Economic Council Director Larry Summers and Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner. In the days before an avoidable June 1 bankruptcy filing, it is imperative that Congress honor its constitutional duties and demand that the GM restructuring deal be sent to it for deliberative review -- before any irreversible measures, such as a voluntary bankruptcy declaration, are taken.

This means delaying any precipitous decisions until after Congress returns from its Memorial Day recess. The case for congressional involvement would be solid enough on constitutional and procedural grounds alone. But the secretive task force's plan raises red flags and requires Congressional examination in open hearings. With the government set to take a 70% ownership stake in GM, there are too many unanswered, troubling questions to proceed with a risky bankruptcy declaration. Here are 10 pressing issues among many:

1) Has the task force conducted any kind of formal or informal cost-benefit analysis on the costs of a GM bankruptcy and excessive closures? These may include the social effects of lost jobs (including more than 100,000 dealership jobs alone), more housing foreclosures, the government expense of providing unemployment and social relief, lost tax revenues, supplier companies that will be forced to close, damaged consumer confidence in the GM brand, and impacts on GM's industrial creditors.

2) Do GM and Chrysler really need to close as many dealerships -- which do not cost manufacturers -- as have been announced? Is the logic of closing dealerships to enable the remaining dealers to charge higher prices? If so, why is the government facilitating such a move

3) Is the task force asking for too many plants to close and the elimination of too many brands?

4) Why is the task force permitting GM to increase manufacturing overseas for export back into the U.S.? Under the GM reorganization plan, the company will rely increasingly on overseas plants to make cars for sale in the U.S., with cars made in low-wage countries like Mexico rising from 15% to 23% of GM sales here. For the first time, GM plans to export cars from China to the U.S. in what is a harbinger of the company's future business model. What is the conceivable rationale for permitting GM to increase manufacturing overseas -- especially in dictatorships, for export back into the U.S. -- when preserving jobs and industry is the avowed goal of this immense taxpayer bailout?

5) Why is the task force supporting GM's efforts to devise a two-tier wage structure, whereby new auto jobs no longer provide a ticket to the middle class?

6) How will bankruptcy affect GM's overseas operations, with special reference to China and GM's corporate entanglements with Chinese partners? Are they and their large profits being exempted from the conditions imposed on domestic operations? Are GM's China-based assets and profits inside or outside of the bankruptcy process?

7) Would a corporate and government-driven bankruptcy process comport with any rights of owner-shareholders to decide whether they want their company to be dissolved?

8) How will bankruptcy affect GM's obligations to parties engaged in pending or future litigation in the courts with GM regarding serious injuries suffered because of design or product defects in vehicles sold prior to the bankruptcy? Or parties engaged in "lemon" litigation?

9) What guarantees are the task force, supposedly representing the taxpayers' investment, obtaining to ensure that the GM of the future invests in safer and more fuel-efficient vehicles?

10) Why is the Obama administration signaling that, after reorganization, when the government owns 70% of GM, it will not exercise the control that attaches to ownership? Many in Congress have been eager to disassociate themselves from the perceived mess of the GM reorganization, believing it too complicated. This is a stark contrast to 1979, when Congress held extensive hearings and passed enacting legislation on the Chrysler bailout and later with the complex Conrail restructuring. If not motivated by their constitutional duty, members of Congress might perhaps listen to political arguments to assert their rightful authority. If GM and the task force take the company into bankruptcy, more than displaced workers will be demanding that Congress answer: "Why are we bailing out the auto companies and then facilitating their moving production overseas? Why aren't we leveraging the public investment to protect jobs and manufacturing capacity, as well as facilitate investments in environmentally appropriate technologies?" It need not be so. The congressional leadership still has a few days to stop the reckless rush to bankruptcy court and to assert its responsibilities.

Mr. Nader is a consumer advocate. Mr. Weissman is editor of Multinational Monitor magazine.

. Printed in The Wall Street Journal, page A15 Copyright 2009 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved
----------------------------------------------------------------------
forcing auto industry into bankrupsy might be one of the most boneheaded economic moves in history. It is not good for anyone involved, except a handful on Wall Street it appears.

Senate after they tossed single payer folks in jail

At the last senate finance committee hearings, after they removed the single payer folks and carted some off to jail; they heard testimony that taxing worker's meager healthcare benefits would be a good idea.

This is from today's Wall Street Journal and is interesting reading.



This is from today's Wall Street journal and is a copyrighted editorial. I shall withdraw if objections made:




http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124355286037664421.html#
REVIEW & OUTLOOK MAY 29, 2009 Taxing Health Care
Obama and Democrats owe John

Politicians wouldn't be politicians if they didn't trim their sails to the
prevailing winds. Even so, the emerging 180-degree turn by Democrats on taxes
and health insurance is one for the record books.


AP
Democrats have spent years arguing that proposals to equalize the tax treatment
of health insurance are an outrage against the American people. Workers pay no
income or payroll taxes on the value of job-based plans, but the same hand isn't
extended to individuals who must buy coverage on their own. Last year liberals
mauled John McCain for daring to touch the employer-based exclusion to finance
more coverage for the individually uninsured. He was proposing "a
multitrillion-dollar tax hike -- the largest middle-class tax hike in history,"
said Barack Obama, whose TV ads were brutal.

But now Democrats need the money to finance $1.2 trillion or more for their new
health insurance entitlement. Last week Senate Finance Chairman Max Baucus
released his revenue "policy options" and high on the list is . . . taxing
health benefits. Or listen to White House budget director Peter Orszag, who
recently told CNN's John King that the exclusion "was not in the President's
campaign plan, it wasn't in our budget. Clearly, some Members of Congress are
putting it on the table and we are going to have to let this play out."

Mr. King tried again. "Let this play out. But would the President sign a bill
that includes a pretty significant tax increase? That would be a tax increase."
Mr. Orszag: "We're not going to be -- I think it's premature to be commenting on
individual items . . . There are lots of ideas that are being put on the table."
Translation: You betcha he'd sign it.

The tax exclusion is such a big revenue prize because Mr. Baucus is scrubbing
every other tax nook and cranny and only coming up with rounding errors. A
sampler:

- Impose an excise tax on hard alcohol, beer and some kinds of wine. That would
be in addition to a sin tax on beverages sweetened with sugar or high-fructose
corn syrup, such as soda. Mr. Baucus doesn't offer revenue estimates, though the
Congressional Budget Office says a $16 per proof gallon alcohol tax might raise
$60 billion over 10 years, and another $50.4 billion at three cents per 12
ounces of sugary drink.

- End or limit the tax-exempt status of charitable hospitals, which only costs
currently a mere $6 billion a year.

- Make college students in work-study programs subject to the payroll tax. Also
targeted are medical residents, perhaps on the principle that they'll one day be
"rich" doctors. CBO has no score on these.

- Reducing Medicare reimbursement rates for supposedly "over valued physician
services," such as diagnostic imaging. CBO says that requiring doctors to get
prior clearance could save $1 billion in 10 years.

- For individuals with high-deductible insurance plans, contributions to health
savings accounts would no longer be tax deductible. That would penalize patients
who choose plans that encourage them to be informed consumers. CBO says that
banning HSA payments entirely would yield all of $10 billion.

By contrast, the employer-based exclusion offers a huge money pot -- an
estimated $226 billion in 2008. Yet as liberal MIT economist Jonathan Gruber
recently told Mr. Baucus's committee, "no health expert today would ever set up
a health system with such an enormous tax subsidy to a particular form of
insurance" (his emphasis). It creates a coverage gap between workers who receive
it from their employers and those who pay -- or can't afford to pay -- with
after-tax money.

The tax exclusion is also one reason health costs continue to rise. It
encourages workers to take an extra dollar of compensation in fringe benefits
instead of cash while also routing low-deductible health spending through third
parties. Some 84 cents of every medical dollar is spent by someone other than
the patient. The insured have no incentives to make cost-conscious decisions
about care.

So reforming the exclusion would inject a dose of discipline into American
medicine. But for most Democrats the goal isn't to create a more rational
health-insurance market. They simply want the revenue for another government
program. Mr. Baucus won't target gold-plated employer insurance plans in
general, because union-negotiated benefits are usually gold-plated. Rather, he
may cap or phase out the exclusion by income, starting with workers earning more
than $200,000. Insurance options that don't conform to government diktats
(health savings accounts) would also lose any tax advantage. This would do
nothing for market efficiency, but it would be one more stealth tax increase.

Democrats owe an apology to Mr. McCain, and it'll be fascinating to see if they
will now suffer a political backlash of their own making. Having told the
country that this tax reform is really a tax increase, Democrats are opening
themselves to the same attacks they leveled against Republicans.

They could avoid that fate if they used the tax exclusion money to finance, say,
a tax credit for the uninsured. That would be a genuinely bipartisan reform. But
liberals won't accept that because they want to take one giant step toward
government-run health care. And the only way they can pay for it is by taxing
everything in sight, including your current health insurance.

-------------------------------------
Taxes and death. Without single payer health insurance, death is a real probability for many an American.

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

GOP and Third World health care in Missouri

As many of you already know, the GOP in Missouri are quite satified with keeping Missouri healthcare in the third world zone. Indeed, to deny some of the poor and working poor health care is a proud goal of the folks in the statehouse in Missouri. Good work folks for once again you have stuck it to the most vunerable of Missouri folks and protected your insurance buddies bottom lines.

Note for the rest of the nation and world: GOP in Missouri do have the guts to stand up for the rich and for business interests and do a fine job at that. Hell, they even had a proposal to refund the stimulus program money to the citizens of Missouri instead of building hospitals, roads, bridges, schools and the like. It is hard to imagine some of the Missouri leaders of the GOP as being able to walk and chew gum at the same time, but like the national GOP they stand united to protect their business buddies.



These are from the folks at Fired Up! Missouri http://www.firedupmissouri.com/



-----------------------------------------------

another worthy healthcare piece from Fired Up Missouri

Monday, May 25, 2009

Bill Moyer's vid b May, 09 single payer healthcare

---------
this is the second snip of the Bill Moyer's Journal discussion of single payer health care. Again, this is copyrighted materials and I shall withdraw if objections
made.

http://www.pbs.org/moyers/journal/05222009/watch2.html

May 22, 2009Washington's abuzz about health care, but why isn't a single-payer plan an option on the table? Public Citizen's Dr. Sidney Wolfe and Physicians for a National Health Program's Dr. David Himmelstein on the political and logistical feasibility of health care reform.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

one of three

------------------------

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

-------------------------------------------------------

------------------------------------

Bill Moyers 5-22-09 Donna Smith interview

-----------------
Below is snip from Bill Moyer's Journal. It is an excellent interview and asks some rather timely questions: http://www.pbs.org/moyers/journal/05222009/watch.html

May 22, 2009
Bill Moyers speaks with advocate Donna Smith about how our broken system is hurting ordinary Americans.
================
this is copyrighted materials and I shall withdraw if objections made. This will be topic for discussion the next Soar meeting in June. Second snip will be in next post and it is copyrighted interview as well.

The purpose of including these vids is for informational purposes. Many folks are interested in "What happened to single-payer" health proposals and it will be remembered at election time for some of folks running for reelection.




----------------------------------